Message to Dr. Hart
From: Aisha
Age: 30
Partner: 42
Duration: 7 years
From: South Africa
Hi Dr. Hart,
My name is Aisha, and I’m 30 years old. My partner, Karim, is 42. We’ve been together for seven years, and we’re from South Africa. Recently, I discovered that Karim has been cheating on me with someone from his office. When I confronted him, he admitted to it and told me it wasn’t just a one-time mistake—it’s been going on for several months. I feel devastated, hurt, and completely lost. I love him, but I don’t know if I can ever trust him again. Should I try to repair our relationship, or is it time to move on? I really don’t know what to do next.
Thank you,
Aisha
Dr. Seraphina Hart’s Response:
Dear Aisha,
First and foremost, I want to acknowledge how incredibly painful and disorienting this must be for you. Infidelity strikes at the core of trust and security in a relationship, shaking the very foundation you’ve built together over the years. It’s not just your partner’s actions that you’re questioning—it’s your whole sense of stability, self-worth, and the future you imagined. The emotions you’re experiencing right now—heartbreak, betrayal, anger, confusion, and even love—are all completely valid. It’s normal to feel overwhelmed, and the range of emotions can make it hard to know what to do next.
This betrayal has likely left you doubting not only Karim but also yourself. You may wonder if you missed the signs, if you’re somehow responsible, or if you’ll ever feel whole again. I want to assure you, Aisha, that none of this is your fault. Trust is given freely in a healthy relationship, and it’s your partner’s responsibility to honor that. When that trust is broken, the path forward—whether you stay or go—can feel daunting. But with time, clarity, and emotional support, healing is possible.
In the coming days, it’s important to remember that the decisions you make should come from a place of emotional empowerment and self-compassion. The journey ahead may be challenging, but by focusing on healing and making thoughtful, intentional choices, you’ll eventually find the clarity you need. Let’s break this process down into manageable steps.
Give Yourself Space to Feel and Process
The initial shock of discovering infidelity can send your emotions into overdrive. You might feel like you’re on a rollercoaster, fluctuating between intense anger, profound sadness, disbelief, and even moments of numbness. These emotions can feel chaotic, but they’re a natural response to the deep wound of betrayal. Give yourself permission to fully feel them without judgment. Sometimes, we’re tempted to bury our pain or rush through it in hopes of regaining control, but true healing starts with allowing yourself to grieve.
Consider finding healthy outlets to process what you’re going through. Journaling can be a powerful way to give voice to your feelings, helping you express thoughts that may feel too raw to share with others. Writing down your thoughts can also help you track your emotional journey over time, allowing you to see progress, even when it feels minimal.
Talking to someone you trust—a close friend or family member—can also provide an immediate source of comfort and perspective. If you feel that the pain is too deep or too complex to handle alone, seeking professional help is an empowering choice. A therapist can offer a safe space to process your emotions and guide you through this difficult time without judgment.
In these early stages, avoid rushing to make any life-altering decisions. Right now, your emotions are likely heightened, and decisions made in the heat of the moment can sometimes lead to regret. Give yourself time to process the shock, and allow the intensity of your feelings to settle before deciding what comes next.
Open a Calm, Honest Dialogue with Karim
Once the initial emotional storm has passed, it’s important to have a calm and honest conversation with Karim. This may seem daunting, especially given the hurt he has caused, but clear communication is essential for you to understand the context of his actions and to determine the potential future of your relationship.
Approach the conversation with the goal of understanding, rather than confrontation. This doesn’t mean excusing his behavior, but it allows you to gather the information you need to make an informed decision. Start by asking direct, open-ended questions, like:
- What led you to cheat, and how did you justify it to yourself?
- Were there problems in our relationship that contributed to your decision?
- Do you genuinely want to repair our relationship, or has your commitment changed?
- Can you fully grasp the depth of the hurt and damage your actions have caused?
These questions can be painful to ask, but they will help you understand the circumstances and whether Karim is ready to take full responsibility for his actions. Pay close attention to his answers—not just the words, but his tone, body language, and level of remorse. Is he truly sorry, or does he seem defensive or dismissive? Genuine remorse and a willingness to be accountable are critical if there’s any hope of rebuilding trust.
If Karim downplays the seriousness of the affair, blames you for his actions, or refuses to take responsibility, these are red flags. On the other hand, if he acknowledges the pain he has caused, accepts full accountability, and expresses a sincere desire to work on the relationship, it may indicate that repair is possible.
Remember, this conversation isn’t about finding closure in one sitting—it’s the beginning of an ongoing dialogue that will require patience, honesty, and emotional vulnerability from both of you.
Understand the Role of Deeper Issues in the Relationship
Infidelity often serves as a symptom of deeper underlying issues, either within the relationship or in the individual who cheated. That doesn’t mean you are to blame for Karim’s actions, but it’s important to consider whether there were problems in your relationship that may have gone unaddressed. Were there ongoing communication problems, unmet emotional needs, or unresolved conflicts that may have contributed to distance between you?
Additionally, consider whether Karim’s behavior reflects personal challenges he’s facing. Sometimes infidelity can be tied to personal insecurities, a need for validation, or even a lack of self-awareness. Understanding the “why” behind his actions can help guide your decision-making process and provide insight into whether the relationship can be repaired.
It’s also crucial to reflect on your own feelings about the relationship before the affair. Were you genuinely happy, or had you already noticed issues that made you feel distant or unfulfilled? Your sense of the relationship’s health before the infidelity will help you decide whether you want to invest in healing or if it’s time to walk away.
Set Boundaries and Non-Negotiables
Whether you decide to stay in the relationship and work through the infidelity or ultimately choose to part ways, setting clear boundaries is crucial for your emotional safety and healing. Boundaries help establish the conditions under which you’re willing to rebuild trust and protect yourself from further hurt. They also provide a roadmap for what needs to change in order for the relationship to survive.
If you decide to give Karim another chance, it’s essential to communicate exactly what you need from him moving forward. Boundaries are not about punishing or controlling your partner; they’re about creating the conditions that make it possible for you to feel safe again. Karim must understand that for the relationship to heal, these boundaries are non-negotiable.
Here are some boundaries you might consider:
- Complete transparency: If Karim is genuinely remorseful and committed to earning back your trust, he should be willing to be completely transparent with you. This could mean sharing access to his phone, email, and social media accounts without hesitation. Transparency is a way to rebuild trust by ensuring that no further secrets are being kept. While some may feel this is an invasion of privacy, in the aftermath of infidelity, privacy must sometimes be sacrificed for the sake of accountability and reassurance.
- Ending all contact with the person he cheated with: This is one of the most fundamental boundaries after an affair. Karim must end all communication with the person he was involved with, and it must be immediate and permanent. Whether this person is a colleague, friend, or someone from a shared social circle, continuing any form of contact is likely to re-trigger feelings of betrayal and insecurity. Make it clear that maintaining even casual communication with this person is unacceptable.
- Agreeing to professional help: Rebuilding a relationship after infidelity often requires external support. Couples counseling can provide a neutral space for both of you to explore the deeper issues that led to the affair and learn new tools for communication and conflict resolution. A counselor can help guide both of you through the complex emotional landscape of rebuilding trust and help address the underlying causes of the infidelity. Insist that counseling is not optional—it’s a necessity if the relationship is to have any chance of surviving.
- Emotional accountability: Karim needs to take full responsibility for the hurt he caused. This means not minimizing, excusing, or justifying his actions. He should be willing to listen to your feelings, acknowledge the pain he’s caused, and remain open to your need to express your emotions without becoming defensive. If he responds to your pain with impatience, dismissiveness, or shifts the blame back onto you, it’s a sign that he may not be capable of the emotional maturity needed to repair the damage.
- Behavioral changes: Aside from transparency, there may be other behaviors that need to change in order for you to feel secure. This might include limiting late-night outings, reducing certain social interactions, or changing routines that contributed to the affair. Establishing these boundaries helps eliminate the factors that led to the betrayal and creates a new framework for trust.
It’s vital that you communicate these boundaries clearly and assertively. Use “I” statements to express how the affair has affected you and why these boundaries are important. For example, “I need transparency to rebuild my trust in you” or “I need you to cut off contact with the other person so I can feel safe in our relationship again.” Boundaries are meant to protect your emotional well-being, and they should reflect your deepest needs as you heal from the betrayal.
If Karim reacts defensively, refuses to honor your boundaries, or shifts the blame back onto you, this may indicate that he is not fully committed to rebuilding the relationship. Blame-shifting and defensiveness are red flags that suggest he hasn’t fully accepted responsibility for his actions, and this can seriously undermine any attempt to move forward together.
Decide Whether to Stay or Move On
After reflecting on the past, having honest conversations with Karim, and setting clear boundaries, you will arrive at the most important decision: whether to stay in the relationship and work through the betrayal, or to move on and begin a new chapter of your life.
This decision is deeply personal, and no one can make it for you. Both paths—staying or leaving—come with their own set of challenges and emotional hurdles, but ultimately, the choice should be based on what is best for your long-term emotional health and happiness.
If You Choose to Stay:
If you decide to stay and work on the relationship, it’s crucial that Karim demonstrates true remorse, takes full responsibility for his actions, and is committed to healing the relationship. Rebuilding trust will take time, and both of you will need to be patient and willing to engage in difficult conversations. There will be moments of pain and doubt along the way, but with effort, it is possible for couples to come out stronger on the other side of infidelity.
However, staying requires more than just Karim’s remorse—it also requires you to feel ready to heal and to genuinely want to move forward. Ask yourself:
- Can I imagine forgiving Karim, even if I can’t forget? Forgiveness is essential for rebuilding, but it’s a process that takes time. You don’t need to forgive him immediately, but over time, if you can’t envision a future where forgiveness is possible, staying might lead to ongoing resentment.
- Do I believe that trust can be rebuilt? Trust is the foundation of any relationship. If, deep down, you feel that you’ll never be able to trust Karim again, even with his efforts, staying in the relationship may only prolong your pain.
- Is Karim demonstrating the commitment needed to heal? It’s important to monitor his behavior and effort in the weeks and months after the affair. Is he putting in the emotional work? Is he being transparent, supportive, and patient with your healing? His ongoing commitment will be a crucial factor in determining whether the relationship can survive.
If You Choose to Leave:
Sometimes, despite a partner’s remorse, the betrayal may be too deep, and you may realize that the trust has been permanently damaged. If you find that the pain of the affair outweighs the love and connection you once had, or if Karim’s actions reflect deeper, ongoing issues, leaving may be the best way to protect your emotional well-being.
Leaving a long-term relationship is never easy, especially after investing so many years together, but it can also be a powerful step toward healing and personal growth. By leaving, you give yourself the opportunity to rebuild your life on your own terms, free from the emotional burden of a broken relationship.
Before deciding to leave, ask yourself:
- Am I prioritizing my own emotional health? If staying in the relationship means constant anxiety, distrust, or emotional distress, it may be time to let go for the sake of your well-being.
- Is this relationship still aligned with my values and goals? If Karim’s infidelity has revealed a fundamental mismatch in your values or long-term goals, leaving may be a necessary step toward living a life that is aligned with your true self.
- Can I envision a future where I am happier without him? Imagine a life beyond this relationship. Does that future feel like a relief, or does it feel incomplete? Visualizing your future can provide clarity in making your decision.
Leaving a relationship, especially one as significant as yours with Karim, is a difficult but courageous choice. It allows you to begin a new journey focused on your healing and personal growth, and it may ultimately lead to a more fulfilling life.
Dr. Seraphina Hart, PhD, is a relationship therapist with over two decades of experience in the field of psychology and human behavior. With a rich academic background from Stanford University, she has an in-depth understanding of the complexities of interpersonal relationships. Dr. Hart's journey began with a deep fascination with the human mind and how it forms emotional connections, leading her to specialize in relationship therapy.
Her compassionate approach and unique methodology are informed by her extensive study of various therapeutic modalities, including Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), and mindfulness techniques. Dr. Hart believes in the power of empathy and understanding in healing and transforming relationships. With her guidance, clients learn to navigate their emotions, communicate effectively, and foster a deep sense of self-awareness.
You may like
How to Improve Communication in a Relationship: Expert Tips for Rebuilding Connection
How to Keep the Spark Alive in Long-Term Relationships
Navigating Different Parenting Styles: Finding Harmony Without Sacrificing Connection